You know the routine. You get home and the bra comes off right away, sometimes before your coat is even on the hook. In the evening, two red marks on your shoulders that just won't fade. The neck and back that you've blamed on your posture or a long day at work for years. And that one drawer full of bras you simply don't wear anymore.
"I don't dare order a bra anymore," a reader wrote to us. "My usual size is 40G: a full cup and a narrow back." Another one: "I don't want to get it wrong again." That's exactly why we run this test. Women with a D, DD, DDD, G or H cup have been struggling to buy bras for years, and most tests act as if S, M or L can replace a cup size.
Our test panel was 5 women with D, DD, DDD, G and H cups, ages 34 to 58. For 6 weeks they wore 5 bras that all sell themselves as made for heavier breasts. Every day we scored them on 6 points: support after 8 hours, pressure from the straps, the shape of the cup, the band riding up, showing through clothes, and the fit after the first wash.
What surprised us: the two bras at the top both cost less than half of an average brand-name bra, and they last longer. The order isn't about price or image. It's about one difference you can measure, and we explain it below: how wide the underband is.
Below is our full top 5, with scores, pros and cons. And why 3 well-known names didn't make it for our panel from a D cup up.